Updated · 4 episodes · 1 show · 4 source notes
Philip Sheridan
Overview
Philip Sheridan was a Union cavalry commander, patron of George Armstrong Custer, and later senior U.S. Army commander who prepared the campaign against non-treaty Lakota and organized the separated columns that preceded the Battle of the Little Bighorn.
Current Profile
The new earliest episode places Sheridan’s relationship with Custer inside the Civil War. He valued the young officer’s cavalry performance, became a consequential patron, and after Appomattox gave Elizabeth Custer the surrender table while praising her husband’s contribution to Union victory. Their bond therefore began in demonstrated wartime ability and symbolic recognition before later political conflict.
The next episode places Sheridan in Reconstruction, where his harder position toward former Confederates and protection of freed people clashed with Custer’s Democratic and pro-Southern politics. Despite that conflict and Custer’s 1867 suspension, Sheridan recalled him because he valued the same Civil War cavalry ability. Custer’s attack on Black Kettle’s village at the Washita Massacre then received Sheridan’s emphatic praise, showing how operational usefulness could outweigh political distrust and prior indiscipline.
The next episode places Sheridan behind renewed railroad protection and exploration on the northern Plains. He sent Custer on the 1873 Yellowstone expedition, praised him after the clashes, and sponsored the 1874 Black Hills expedition while warning him to limit journalists. After gold publicity triggered a rush, Sheridan initially tried to exclude miners, showing a tension between military exploration and enforcement of territorial restrictions.
The later episode places Sheridan at the November 1875 White House meeting where the Grant administration decided to stop enforcing restrictions against Black Hills intruders while imposing a winter deadline on non-treaty Lakota. After the deadline passed, he received authority to prepare for war, making his military planning the operational arm of Manufactured War Pretext.
His initial winter campaign failed in severe weather, except for George Crook’s attack on a Cheyenne village, which pushed survivors toward the growing Native coalition. Sheridan then organized a summer convergence under Crook, Alfred Terry, and John Gibbon. He did not lead it personally because William Tecumseh Sherman wanted him available for possible federal intervention amid the violent collapse of Reconstruction in the South.
Key Characteristics
- He first sponsored Custer after proven Civil War cavalry performance, then repeatedly restored him when effectiveness outweighed political distrust and disciplinary risk.
- He moved from attempted miner exclusion to translating federal policy into a campaign against non-treaty Lakota.
- His winter plan underestimated environmental limits and produced little operational success.
- His summer plan depended on separated columns converging across great distances.
- The campaign lacked reliable communications and a shared current picture.
- His absence links Plains operations to federal military obligations during Reconstruction’s collapse.
Evidence
- Civil War patronage: 446. Custer vs. Crazy Horse: Civil War (Part 1) connects Sheridan’s recognition of Custer’s cavalry ability to the symbolic gift of the Appomattox surrender table.
- Reconstruction and Custer’s recall: 447. Custer vs. Crazy Horse: The Winning of the West (Part 2) connects their political differences, Custer’s suspension, Sheridan’s restoration of him, and praise after Washita.
- Expedition sponsorship: 450. Custer’s Last Stand: Death in the Black Hills (Part 5) connects Sheridan to the 1873 Yellowstone and 1874 Black Hills expeditions, press limits, praise of Custer, and initial miner exclusion.
- Policy-to-war transition: 451. Custer’s Last Stand: The Charge of the 7th Cavalry (Part 6) places Sheridan in the secret meeting and subsequent war preparation.
- Winter failure: 451. Custer’s Last Stand: The Charge of the 7th Cavalry (Part 6) describes weather stopping Terry and Gibbon and Crook’s counterproductive village attack.
- Summer design: 451. Custer’s Last Stand: The Charge of the 7th Cavalry (Part 6) identifies the three columns, their routes, and their communication limits.
- Reconstruction context: 451. Custer’s Last Stand: The Charge of the 7th Cavalry (Part 6) explains why Sherman retained Sheridan away from direct field command.
Qualifications
- This is a campaign-specific profile based on two popular-history episodes, not a full assessment of Sheridan’s military or political career.
- The source’s claim that the administration deliberately engineered war remains an interpretation of policy sequence and timing.
- The episode does not establish whether different nineteenth-century communications could have made the convergence reliable.
- Reconstruction context explains Sheridan’s absence but does not by itself establish how his presence would have changed the campaign.
- Washita casualty figures, target attribution, and the episode’s massacre judgment require evidence beyond Sheridan’s victory assessment.
- The surrender-table story and the episode’s account of Sheridan’s praise are source-scoped and do not provide a complete history of their Civil War command relationship.
What Changed
- Extended the relationship with Custer backward to Civil War performance and Appomattox recognition.
- Clarified that later restoration rested on an already established judgment of cavalry ability.
Relationships
- Manufactured War Pretext - political sequence that preceded his authorization to prepare for war.
- George Crook - commander of the southern column.
- Alfred Terry - commander of the Dakota column.
- John Gibbon - commander of the Montana column.
- Campaign Coordination Without Communication - central weakness of his operational design.
- Lakota People - people targeted by the campaign after the winter deadline.
- Black Hills - region where his expedition sponsorship and enforcement problem converged.
- Washita Massacre - attack he praised as a complete military success despite its enduring controversy.
- Punitive Village Warfare - framework for the winter campaign method he endorsed.
- George Armstrong Custer - subordinate whose wartime effectiveness sustained Sheridan’s patronage through later conflict.
Sources
4 source notes across 1 show
- 451. Custer's Last Stand: The Charge of the 7th Cavalry (Part 6) The Rest Is History
- 450. Custer's Last Stand: Death in the Black Hills (Part 5) The Rest Is History
- 447. Custer vs. Crazy Horse: The Winning of the West (Part 2) The Rest Is History
- 446. Custer vs. Crazy Horse: Civil War (Part 1) The Rest Is History